Obviously they shouldn't change it as the game is largely a time capsule, but I always wish it was 0.1/0.5% etc. was top% of your class for these rewards. Really sucks that a lot of players simply don't even have a shot at these simply because of the class they play and all the spots will be taken up by the usual suspects.
They should have implemented the new title/rewards in season 2, where everyone will have equal gear (full S1 pvp gear from honor). This first season will be people in raid gear, kara, atiesh, thunderfury ect. Watch any streamer like the god-awful 'jokerd', he's in full raid gear, absolutely no clue how to play his class, doesn't counterspell, polymorph, or anything, just instant pyroblast. I'll save my 75k honor and badges for S2.
I got 248 points with an 880 rated 3v3 team, the calculators appear to be wrong - the wiki says there was the new formula implemented in september 2007 so presumably season 1 used a different formula and could be the case in classic season 1 as well?
The arena points calculator doesnt work at all. My arena points i get in wow was different too from what it was shown on calculator.
If you get so little points from winning, why would you spend it on the arena weapons? It's much easier to craft one or do Karazhan. Right now it seems you need to do over month of arena to even get a weapon.